Grand Duchess Maria Vladimirovna and her justified claim to the Imperial throne of Russia

H.I.H Grand Duchess Maria Vladimirovna with her mother Grand Duchess Vladimir in Madrid.

Grand Duchess Maria Vladimirovna  attended the same school that I did in Madrid: Runnymede College, where we prepared ourselves for our “O” and “A” Levels of Cambridge University. I have had the honour of knowing Her Imperial Highness since those days. I was invited to the baptism of her son and heir, Grand Duke George at their family home in Puerta de Hierro in Madrid. Their Majesties King Juan Carlos and Queen Sophia of Spain attended the celebration as the relationship between the Spanish Royal House and the Vladimirovichs has always been excellent.

On the death of her father, Grand Duke Vladimir Kyrillovich  in Miami on the 21 April 1992, she became the Head of the Imperial House of Russia though the Romanov Family Association do not recognize her as such, for reasons that in my opinion are mistaken and that will be discussed further on in my article. It is important to note, as gestures are sometimes more important than words, that the Grand Duke’s body was returned to Russia and was buried with full pomp and splendour in the Peter and Paul Fortress in St. Petersburg , the first Romanov to be honoured in this way since before the revolution.

To be able to understand the complicated laws of succession to the Imperial throne we must turn to the Pauline Laws. The Pauline Laws are the house laws of the House of Romanov and the name comes from the fact that they were initially established by Emperor Paul I in 1797.

Tsar Paul I abolished Peter the Great’s  law which allowed each reigning emperor or empress to designate his or her successor, substituting a strict order of succession by proclaiming that the eldest son of the monarch shall inherit the throne, and other dynasts according to primogeniture in the male-line. In so doing, Tsar Paul implemented a semi-Salic line of succession to the Russian throne: The throne could henceforth pass to a female and through the female (cognatic)  line of the dynasty, upon the extinction of all legitimately-born, male dynasts.

The Pauline laws established a very strict marriage policy. The ruling Tsar had to approve all marriages and only those to members of a Royal or Ruling family, were considered dynastic and acceptable. I suggest you read further details on this matter by clicking on the following link:

http://https://www.wikiwand.com/en/Pauline_Laws

After the forced abdication of Nicholas II on the 15th March 1917 in his name and that of his son, his brother Grand Duke Michael was proclaimed “Emperor Michael II,” to Russian troops and in cities throughout Russia but the new Emperor deferred to the will of the people and acknowledged the Provisional Government as the de facto executive, but neither abdicated nor refused to accept the throne. In his statement he said:

“Inspired, in common with the whole people, by the belief that the welfare of our country must be set above everything else, I have taken the firm decision to assume the supreme power only if and when our great people, having elected by universal suffrage a Constituent Assembly to determine the form of government and lay down the fundamental law of the new Russian State, invest me with such power.
Calling upon them the blessing of God, I therefore request all the citizens of the Russian Empire to submit to the Provisional Government, established and invested with full authority by the Duma, until such time as the Constituent Assembly, elected within the shortest possible time by universal, direct, equal and secret suffrage, shall manifest the will of the people by deciding upon the new form of government.”

His Majesty Tsar Nicholas II when he was Tsarevich

Grand Duke Michael Alexandrovich, brother of Tsar Nicholas II and proclaimed Tsar Michael II

Tsar Kyril I

After the fall of the monarchy and the disappearance of  Tsar Nicholas II and his family in Ekateringburg, (I am yet to be convinced of the generally accepted official  version of the assassination and its important to not forget that the Russian Orthodox Church to this day  has not recognised the authenticity of the remains and declined to attend the reburial ceremony in 1998) Grand Duke Nikolai Nikolaievich  was proclaimed as the emperor of all Russia by the Zemsky Sobor of the Priamursk Region (Provisional Priamurye Government) which controlled portions of the Russian Far East, convened in Vladivostok by General Mikhail Diterikhs, who appreciated his career as general and former commander-in-chief, and his position as the oldest member of the imperial dynasty. At the time, Grand Duke Nicholas was already living abroad and consequently was not present at the Sobor. Two months later the Priamursk region fell to the Bolsheviks thus his rule was nominal as he was living  in exile during the entirety of his reign that ended when he died in 1929 without issue. In any case, Dowager Empress Maria Feodorovna who was living in exile  in Denmark, did not take seriously this proclamation as she believed until her death on the 13th October 1928 that Her son and grandchildren had not been murdered.

Her Imperial Majesty Dowager Empress Maria Feodorovna in Denmark after the fall of the monarchy.

Despite, the Dowager Empress’ believes, camps started to be formed in the monarchist movement, where Paris was a focal location. Several monarchists grouped around Grand Duke Cyril Vladimirovich, who was first in the line of succession by male primogeniture after the alleged murder of Tsar Nicholas II, Tsareich Alexei and Grand Duke Michael Alexandrovich. Many of Kyril’s opponents grouped around a young Grand Duke Dimitri Pavlovich, who was next in the line of succession if Cyril and his brothers, the Vladimirovichi, were ineligible (Paul Alexandrovich, who had been ahead of Dmitri, had been killed in 1919), but Dimitri himself refused these advances, supporting instead Grand Duke Kyril as emperor. In any case, neither Grand Duke Nikolai Nikolaievich or Grand Duke Dimitri Pavlovich proclaimed there rights to the throne out of respect to the feelings of the Dowager Empress but Kyril

Grand Duke Kyril Vladimirovich who proclaimed himself Tsar Kyril I on the 31st August 1924.

Vladimirovich assumed on 8 August 1922 the position of curator of the throne and on 31 August 1924 he proclaimed himself Kyril I, Emperor of all the Russias. With the assumption of the Imperial title, his children were elevated to the title and styles of Grand Duke and Grand Duchesses of Russia according to the Statutes of the Imperial Family and the Laws of the Russian Empire. Grand Duke Kyril’s role as head of the House was recognised, and the oath of loyalty signed by every male dynast of the House of Romanov, except Grand Duke Nicholas, his brother Grand Duke Peter, and the latter’s son, Prince Roman Petrovich.  Tsar Kyril held his court-in-exile in France, erecting a secretariat for the monarchist movement until his death in 1938 when his only son, Grand Duke Vladimir Kyrillovich, succeeded him as “de jure”  Emperor though he chose to assume the title of “Grand Duke” rather than that of Emperor. Sadly for the family this succession would be surrounded by controversy and to understand the reason for the controversy we must go back to the Pauline Laws.

His Imperial Highness Vladimir Kyrillovich Romanov, Grand Duke of Russia

Controversy with the interpretation of the Pauline Laws

As mentioned previously, the Pauline Laws were very strict in regard to dynastic marriages and the laws provide for succession by both male and female dynasts and establishing male-preference primogeniture. This means that succession to the throne (or headship of the dynasty) passes by primogeniture to the senior male dynast. At the death of the last male dynast, the succession passes to the female dynast most closely related to the last emperor.

Grand Duke Vladimir married Princess Leonida Georgievna Bagration-Moukhransky on the 13th August 1948 in Lausanne. The Pauline Laws dictated that only those born of a dynastic marriage between a Romanov dynast and a member of a “royal or sovereign house”, were included in the Imperial line of succession; children of morganatic or unequal marriages were ineligible to inherit the throne or dynastic status. For the supporters of Grand Duke Vladimir he was the sole male dynast of the Imperial House to enter into an equal marriage after the 1917 revolution but his opponents refuted the equality of this marriage and they do so to this day.

Her Royal Highness Princess Leonida Bagration-Moukhransky who became Her Imperial Highness Grand Duchess Vladimir after her marriage.

The family to which Princess Leonida belonged, the Bagrationi dynasty, had been kings in Georgia from the medieval era until the early 19th century, but no male line ancestor of hers had reigned as a king in Georgia since 1505 and her branch of the Bagrations, the House of Moukhransky, had been naturalised among the non-ruling  nobility of Russia after Georgia was annexed to the Empire in 1801. Yet the royal status of the House of Bagration had been recognized by Russia in the 1783 Treaty of Georgievsk and was confirmed by Vladimir Kyrillovich on 5 December 1946 as head of the Russian imperial house.  Therefore this controversy fueled by some members of the family, has no legal standing specially in view that the Republic of Georgia later recognized the Bagrations as their royal family and invited the head of the family back to Georgia. This means that it is a fact that Grand Duke Vladimir Kyrillovich was the sole male dynast of the Imperial House to enter into an equal marriage after the revolution.

In any case, in 1946, in his capacity as Head of the Russian Imperial Family, Grand Duke Vladimir recognised the Moukhransky branch of the House of Bagration as a former Royal dynasty and he declared his marriage to Princess Leonida to be dynastic, notwithstanding her family’s status as Russian subjects at the end of the monarchy. From the time of their marriage in 1948 she assumed her husband’s rank, bearing the title Grand Duchess of Russia and the style Her Imperial Highness.

For further information on this please click on the following link:

Georgia considering restoring the monarchy

In 1969 Grand Duke Vladimir, expressing his opinion that the House of Romanov faced almost inevitable extinction in the dynastic male line,  proclaimed his daughter Grand Duchess Maria Vladimirovna the future curatrix of the throne, implying that she would ultimately succeed.

In 1989, when Prince Vasili Alexandrovich of Russia (who was also the President of the Romanov Family Association) died, Grand Duke Vladimir proclaimed his daughter as the dynasty’s heiress, as Prince Vasili was the last male Romanov other than himself whom, having been born of an equal marriage, was recognized as a dynast.

For nearly two centuries, from the accession of Emperor Paul I in 1796 to the death of Grand Duke Vladimir in 1992, male dynasts held the throne or headship of the dynasty, based on primogeniture. Due to the numerous non-dynastic marriages that occurred after the Revolution of 1917, the male dynasts of the Imperial House grew smaller in number as the years passed and finally died out in 1992 when Grand Duke Vladimir Kyrillovich died in 1992. With no existing male dynasts, Maria Vladimirovna assumed the position of Head of the House  as “de jure” Empress and proclaimed her son George Mikhailovich as  heir-apparent. Since that day she has worked tirelessly to promote the sentiment of monarchy in Russia with great success.

Her Imperial Highness Maria Vladimirovna Romanov, Grand Duchess of Russia

Her Imperial Highness Grand Duchess Maria Vladirmirovna on her dynastic coming of age on her 16th birthday.

The Grand Duchess was born in Madrid, where her parents resided since the end of the II World War. Her godfather was H.R.H Prince Nicholas of Romania and her  godmother,Queen Ioanna of Bulgaria. She was educated in Madrid and Paris, before studying Russian history and literature at Oxford University and is  fluent in Russian, English, French and Spanish, and also speaks some German, Italian and Arabic.

On 23 December 1969, upon reaching her dynastic majority, Grand Duchess Maria swore an oath of loyalty to her father, to Russia, and to uphold the Fundamental Laws of Russia which governed succession to the Imperial throne. At the same time, her father issued a controversial decree recognizing her as heiress and declaring that, in the event he predeceased other dynastic Romanov males, then the Grand Duchess would become the “Curatrix” “of the Imperial Throne until the death of the last male dynast. The heads of the other branches of the imperial family, declared that Grand Duke Vladimir’s actions were not legal but as it happened he outlived all the other male Romanov dynasts, and thus Grand Duchess Maria had no occasion to assume curatorship but directly became “de jure” Empress of Russia.

The Russian Legitimist Organization agrees with this. They have stated that as there are no male dynasts, the succession to the headship of the dynasty has passed legally to Grand Duchess Maria Vladimirovna because she is the surviving female dynast most closely related to the last emperor, Tsar Nicholas II (or Michael II) but the Romanov Family Association is not in agreement with this point of view or this interpretation of the Pauline Laws. In my opinion they are wrong.

On 22 September 1976, the Grand Duchess married His Royal and Imperial Highness Prince Franz Wilhelm of Prussia, her third cousin, once-removed. He is a great-grandson of Germany’s last emperor, Kaiser Wilhelm II and a great-great-great grandchild of Queen Victoria of the United Kingdom. Franz Wilhelm converted to the Orthodox faith prior to the wedding, taking the name Michael Pavlovich and receiving the title of a Grand Duke of Russia from Grand Duke Vladimir.

They separated in 1982, a year after the birth of their only child, George Mikhailovich, who had been granted the title Grand Duke of Russia at birth by his grandfather.

Grand Duchess Vladimir with her husband Grand Duke Vladimir and Grand Duke George Mikhailovich and his mother Grand Duchess Maria Vladimirevna.

The “de jure” Empress hopes for the restoration of the monarchy someday and is “ready to respond to a call from the people”. When questioned about the ongoing rift among Romanov descendants, the Empress said:

“Attempts to disparage my rights have originated with people who, firstly, do not belong to the Imperial Family, and, secondly, either do not themselves know the relevant laws or think that others do not know these laws. In either case, there is unscrupulousness at work. The only thing that causes me regret is that some of our relatives waste their time and energy on little intrigues instead of striving to be of some use to their country. I have never quarreled with anyone about these matters and I remain open to discussions and cooperation with all, including, of course, my relatives. But there can be no foundation for cooperation without respect for our dynastic laws, fulfilling these laws, and following our family traditions”

 

Despite the dispute between Grand Duchess Maria and the Romanov Family Association the reality is that she is acknowledged as Head of the Russian Imperial House by all the European Royal Houses.

Grand Duchess Maria Vladimirovna with Her Majesty Queen Elisabeth II at the Ivy in London

The “de jure” Empress of Russia, with her son Tsarevich George and His Majesty Tsar Simeon of Bulgaria and His Majesty King Michael of Romania.

On the 23rd of May 2010, Her Imperial Highness Grand Duchess Vladimir died in Madrid at the age of 96. She was the last member of the Russian Imperial Family to have been born before the revolution. Her body was flown to St. Petersburg to be buried alongside the body of her late husband, Grand Duke Vladimir Kyrillovich in the Peter and Paul Fortress.

The Romanov Family Association

In 1979, seven undisputed male and female dynasts founded the Romanov Family Association (RFA), which by the end of the same year had admitted more than half of the surviving undisputed dynasts into its membership, as well as a fair number of those male-line descendants that Grand Duke Vladimir did not recognize as dynasts because of morganatic birth. Grand Duke Vladimir Kyrillovich never joined the association and neither has Grand Duchess Maria.

The RFA, which included the last two surviving females recognised as dynasts among its membership, chose Prince Nicholas Romanov, as its president in 1989, following the death of Prince Vasili Alexandrovich of Russia, the only undisputed male dynast still living at that time other than  Grand Duke Vladimir Kyrilovich. The RFA’s official position, expressed in its founding charter, is that the Russian nation should determine which sort of government its people desire and, if the choice is monarchy, who should be monarch. Nonetheless, once  Grand Duke Vladimir was no longer alive, they recognised Prince Nicholas Romanov as the head of the Imperial House of Romanov while serving as third president of the RFA. Nicholas took ” His Highness Prince of Russia” as his his title  following the death of  Grand Duke Vladimir Kyrillovich.

After Nicholas’ death in 2014, his brother Prince Dimitri Romanov took up the claim. In July 2009 Dimitri had affirmed that his brother Nicholas, and not Grand Duchess Maria Vladimirovna, was the Head of the Imperial Family, simultaneously declaring, however, that pursuant to a 1992 family meeting he attended in Paris, all of the then living senior male descendants of the House of Romanov agreed not to put forward any claim. Prince Dimitri died childless in 2016, extinguishing the asserted claims of the Romanovs of the Nikolaievich branch with the death of the last male of that line.

The RFA to this day continues its dispute with Grand Duchess Maria and her son. They refuse to acknowledge her as the “de jure” Empress. They do not even recognize her title of Grand Duchess and insist that when she married  Prince Franz Wilhelm, she became a Princess of Prussia! This idea is ludicrous as by the thinking of the RFA’s members then for example, Queen Margrethe II of Denmark would be only the Countess of Monpezat, the former Queen Beatriz of the Dutch would have been Mrs von Amsberg or Queen Elizabeth II, princess of Greece and Denmark!  Absurd to say the least!

The current members of the RFA who most of them are the morganatic descendants of the dynasty and who do not have any rights to the Imperial throne, have chosen to forget that Grand Duke Kyril Vladimirovich’s role as head of the Imperial House was recognized, and the oath of loyalty signed by EVERY male dynast of the House of Romanov, except Grand Duke Nicholas, his brother Grand Duke Peter, and the latter’s son, Prince Roman Petrovich. This means that as Head of the Imperial House, his and his successor’s decisions related to the Imperial House became law for all Romanov family members.  I believe that is would be more patriotic and useful for the cause of the monarchy that all the members of the Romanov family rally around Grand Duchess Maria and support her claim to the Imperial throne. Leaving aside her solid dynastic claim she is after all the most widely accepted candidate inside and outside of Russia.

The Line of Succession

The heir presumptive is His Imperial Highness George Mikhailovich, Grand Duke of Russia and born in 1981. The Grand Duke is currently unmarried. In the unlikely case that he does not have an heir, the succession would then follow semi- Salic law and the right to the Imperial Crown will presumably pass to Andreas, Prince of Leiningen, as the nearest male relation to the “de jure” Empress and her son that is not descended from Grand Duke Cyril Vladimirovich through morganatic marriage.

The heir apparent: George, Grand Duke of Russia

Absurdly, the eldest brother of Prince Andreas of Leiningen, Prince Karl Emich of Leiningen who now is known is currently calling himself Nikolai Kyrillovich, has converted from the Lutheran religion to the  Russian Orthodox faith and with the support of the Russian Monarchical Party of the Russian Federation ( the only monarchical political party in Russia) in 2013, he was proclaimed Tsar Nicholas III. The reality is that Prince Karl Emich, though the eldest brother of Prince Andreas, did not inherit the headship of the House of Leiningen because of his second morganatic marriage to Gabriele Thyssen. His third wife is Countess Isabelle von und zu Egloffstein and the marriage is also considered morganatic for both the Leiningen and Romanov houses, thus his claim to the Russian Imperial throne is not in accordance to the Pauline Laws!

https://www.wikiwand.com/en/Prince_Karl_Emich_of_Leiningen

Conclusions

  1. Grand Duchess Maria Vladimirovna, has been prepared since her birth to become the Head of the Imperial family.
  2. She has worked tirelessly  to promote the restoration of the monarchy in Russia.
  3. She is recognised as Head of the Imperial Family by the Russian government.
  4. She has the support of most monarchist groups and followers, most societies of Russian nobles — including the Assembly of the Russian Nobility.
  5. In March 2013, her claim was recognised by the head of the Russian Orthodox Church, Kyril I, Patriarch of Moscow and all Russia and this has drawn further supporters among Russians to her cause and the possibility of the restoration of the monarchy. In an interview, the patriarch firmly rejected the claims of the other Romanov descendants and stated, “Today, none of those persons who are descendants of the Romanovs are pretenders to the Russian throne. But in the person of Grand Duchess Maria Vladimirovna and her son, George, the succession of the Romanovs is preserved — no longer to the Russian Imperial throne, but to history itself.”

The “de jure” Empress of Russia

The Russian Imperial Family

Though the restoration of the monarchy in Russia is discussed by the press with regularity and even politicians (including of the ruling party), have openly called for a restoration, it does not seem as it could happen in the short term. But the support of the restoration is growing. In  early 2017, a survey conducted by Izvestia found that of young Russians 37% supported the restoration of the monarchy. This is evidently a result of the Grand Duchess’ good work and her  rising appeal with the Russian people.

I admire Grand Duchess Maria’s dedication to promoting the sentiment of monarchy in Russia. There is no doubt that she is succeeding in her efforts and personally as a firm believer in monarchy and a staunch royalist, I wish her success. I have no doubt she will be an excellent constitutional leader.

 

http://www.express.co.uk/news/world/586470/Russia-royal-family-Vladimir-Putin-reinstate-Tsar-Nicholas-Second-Romanov

http://www.newsweek.com/putins-crimea-chief-calls-restoring-russian-monarchy-568361

http://http://www.russianlegitimist.org/news-blog/2017/1/28/2017-01-09-an-interview-with-the-head-of-the-russian-imperial-house-in-rossiia-nasledie

https://www.theguardian.com/world/2017/mar/06/russia-revolution-tsarist-school-moscow-nicholas-ii

 

Links:

http://www.russianlegitimist.org/

http://www.imperialhouse.ru/en/

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

Published by

Carlos Mundy

Carlos Mundy, the current Count of Mondaye ( a Norman title that dates back to the XI century!) , was born in Bilbao (Spain) but lived in London until the age of twelve, when he moved to Madrid (Spain) with his parents and brothers. He studied in Spain and went to University to study journalism. During those years he was already working as a freelance journalist for several Spanish magazines. AT the age of 19 he took off on a round the world tour for two years working as a model to make ends meet. On his return he founded a model agency in 1982 which he managed until 1996 and became the top agency in Spain with offices in Madrid and Barcelona. During those years he traveled the world extensively on scouting trips and he also continued working as a freelance journalist doing interviews to top fashion designers, heads of state and celebrities. He also wrote many travel pieces: his passion. In the year 2000 he founded Metaphore Magazine: Creative Culture, a must read in the Spanish publishing scene. The magazine was a monthly that lasted two years. In 2003 he published the Spanish version of The Rainbow Warrior, co- written with his sister Charis and that was published in the US in 2007. His next book, The Toucan Lodge was published simultaneously in the UK and the US in 2009 and its Spanish publication in 2010. The novel was re-released in the UK in 2011 under the title Gestapo Lodge. This was followed by the publication of the successful historical novel, "The Romanov Lost Icon and the Enigma of Anastasia" (Thames River Press) in 2013, co-written with historian Marie Stravlo. 2015 has seen the publication of an epic fantasy co-written again with his sister Charis, "The Twilight of the Fourth World," inspired by the teachings of His Holiness The Dalai Lama and the Hopi Indian prophecies. Before the end of the year his latest historical novel, "The Indian Kings of France: The fascinating story of the Bourbons of Bhopal" is expected to be published. Carlos is currently working on the production of Unforgettable, a tribute to the Legends of Hollywood which is scheduled to start shooting in Jodphur (India) in 2017 with a fabulous cast of legends. Carlos is a show jumper and when time permits, he continues to paint. He had two successful exhibits in the nineties. He is also a member of The Comite de APoyo al Tibet. The Spanish NGO, that has lobbied successfully to have the Spanish courts start criminal proceedings against Chinese Communist leaders for Crimes against Humanity committed in occupied Tibet. He was made a Knight of the Royal Order of the Principality of Hutt River in 2007, became a Knight of the Ecumenic Order of Malta in 2011 and received THE WOMEN TOGETHER AWARD at the United Nations for his philanthropic anonymous work with Tibet. He is currently Chancellor of Foreign Affairs of the Ecumenical Knights of Malta.

2 thoughts on “Grand Duchess Maria Vladimirovna and her justified claim to the Imperial throne of Russia”

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *